![]() ![]()
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
11A076
Blood Money
by Jim Davies, 3/18/2011
![]() In the nearest thing to real justice that I recall seeing recently, Raymond Davis was freed a couple of days ago from a Pakistani prison, after someone - probably you and I, without our consent - had paid his victims' families over $2 million in compensation. It's a complicated affair. Davis shot and killed two men in Lahore who tried to car-jack him while stuck in traffic, and he says he shot them in self defense. Assuming that to be true, in a civilized society he would not have been long detained. Everyone has that natural right. If witnesses confirmed the facts, he'd have been on his way after a few hours at most.
Pakistani law provides however that if a victim or his family forgives an aggressor, the government case is dropped; and that is what caught my attention as a rather enlightened idea. Government ought not to be involved at all, but that practice reflects what was done in mediaeval Iceland; if someone killed a person, he went to the victim's family to apologize and offer compensation in the form of wergeld or, if you will, blood money. A court got involved only if the amount could not be agreed between the parties concerned. In this case, the victims' families' lawyer strongly opposed such a settlement (I wonder why?) but as it happened he too was in jail at the time (I did say it was complex) and a deal was done without his participation. Loaded with rupees, the families then relocated rapidly lest their neighbors expressed indignation, foamed at the mouth, organized a rupee raid, etc. Davis isn't quite out of the woods yet; he has to face an inquiry back home by the people who paid his ransom, in case that story about self-defense happens to have been less than perfectly true. But at least he won't be torn limb from limb by a vengeful mob of our grateful friends. So far, though, the story happens to illustrate what real justice is all about: righting wrongs, restoring damaged rights. In the coming zero government society, there will be no other kind.
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |